Much of the body positive movement will have you believe that self-love, acceptance and confidence will heal you from body shame and disordered eating. But the emotion that was most transformational for me in healing my anorexia and body shame was not any of these high vibrational, pure emotions. It was anger. Let me explain. I was studying politics at a heavily-social-justice-focused liberal arts school called Occidental college. And I was starving myself. Half of my attention went to being a top student, and the other half went to body-checking and calorie counting. Fortuitously, amidst the thick of my eating disorder, I was studying how dominant narratives (myths that are collectively believed by a society, construed by the group in power to better themselves), guide each of our lives in unseen and often detrimental ways. I was studying how black people and immigrants have historically been compared to animals in order to justify the atrocities that we have committed against them. And how these demeaning comparisons about a specific demographic are always most prevalent around the time that the greatest atrocities are being committed against that demographic. I was studying how the intelligence, sentience, and emotionality of animals whom we eat and wear is diminished and erased from collective understanding. While the intelligence, sentience, and emotionality of animals whom we keep as pets is elevated and glorified. I was studying how women’s bodies have historically been pathologized by the medical community. How women’s illnesses have been trivialized and blamed on mental instability. And how women’s sexuality has been problematized and even criminalized. I began to see a theme. The stories that we are told by our society serve to otherize the groups that are exploited by our society. These fables serve to diminish the moral responsibility we feel towards the subjugated groups. And these fables serve to allow the group in power to control, manipulate and profit off of the demoralized groups. I was also studying how in a capitalist system, supply does not just meet demand, but suppliers create demand. Capitalism works when your needs are continually manufactured and implanted in the ideas of buyers. Capitalism thrives off of collective dissatisfaction. I began putting all of this together and came to a startling realization. My eating disorder and body shame was, in large part, manufactured by a society that WANTS women to hate themselves. I Started Questioning I started to question all of the beliefs that led to my eating disorder and body shame: —the more fat a person has, the less healthy they are —that some bodies are inherently more worthy of love than others —cellulite is a problem —my weight is fully in my control —diets are effective —weight loss will make me healthier —hunger is dangerous and I am strong if I can control my cravings The truth emerged. I poured through book after book, only to discover that NONE of these beliefs were true. Health has very little to do with weight; there are no “good” bodies and “bad” bodies; 98% of women have cellulite and it’s completely healthy; our bodies have a natural weight range at which they are healthiest and happiest, which varies from person to person and there’s nothing we can do to change it; diets don’t work, weight loss is not necessarily correlated to getting healthier (often it’s inversely correlated); cravings need to be listened to, not ignored. WHEW!! I was dumbfounded. Every belief that engendered my eating disorder was categorically untrue. The Anger I realized that the female population is fed with myths that pathologies our healthy, normal excess flesh and cellulite and myths that problematize our healthy, normal hunger and cravings. Myths that make us hate ourselves and compete with each other, thereby holding our entire gender back from creating the societal change we could create if we banned together. I realized that my negative body image wasn’t a personal flaw or just one more thing I couldn’t seem to get right. It was actually a result of toxic cultural programming designed to make me feel insecure and then profit off of our shame. My society was sponsoring body shame in me, and in almost every woman I knew. The realization. I came to the startling conclusion that the way we have been taught to treat our bodies is pervasively violent. You are taught to believe “If you have excess flesh on your body, then you should either starve yourself, cut it off, or continue hiding your body and hating yourself.” This is not just any kind of violence. It is state sanctioned violence. That means that our capitalist, patriarchal culture is actually benefiting from and profiting off of our body shame, insecurity and fear of fat. So they perpetuate myths and lies that keep us on a futile quest to “fix” our bodies. Dieting is a political sedative that pits women against each other, sucks our cognitive functioning and keeps us as second class citizens. We waste so much of our time and money trying to conform to an arbitrary, meaningless beauty ideal, and hating ourselves when we biologically can’t. The lies. In other words, we are oppressing ourselves by believing the lies that our society tells us. Lies that engender shame, insecurity, competition and fear within and amongst us. Lies that keeps us on a futile quest to buy the “right products” and try the “right diet” that will make us thin and beautiful. I had been trying for years to just love and accept my body and be confident. Those were not the emotions I needed. I needed anger. I needed to get pissed. People were actually benefiting from and profiting off of my shame and fear. In the paraphrased words of Rupi Kaur, we are collectively comfortable with the pornification of women. The sexualization of women. The objectification of women. The violence and degradation of women. But we can’t be bothered to express our disgust about this. About the fact that the objectification of
The Solution to Your Binge Eating Struggles
Before you can find a solution to binge eating, you have to understand what the problem actually is. In my last article I wrote about understanding why you can’t stop binging. The solution to binge eating: So, now you know what’s at the root of your binge eating. So what’s the solution? At the risk of sounding totally woo woo and cliche, it looks like love. Broadly, the solution looks like radical self-love, forgiveness, compassion and acceptance. It looks like surrendering all fear of any “bad” part of ourselves and making room for wholeness. It looks like increasing our capacity to tenderly nurture and love ourselves. The solution involves stopping our inner dictator’s attempts to beat down our inner “punishable offender” and our attempt to avoid our internal experiences. It means replacing the belief system of “it’s necessary for me to be upset with and punish myself in order for me to improve,” with beliefs like: ”The more joyful I am, the healthier I am,” “Dissatisfaction with my body doesn’t motivate me as much as gratitude and inspiration,” and “I welcome the experience of pleasure and fullness in my body.” Shame ≠ happiness I see so many people adopting a “commitment to health” from a place of fear, insecurity, guilt and/or shame. But shame does not lead to happiness. Fear does not lead to abundance. Guilt does not lead to acceptance. Insecurity does not lead to motivation. We need to step out of the world of right and wrong when we think about food and our bodies. Caring about our health is not the “right” thing to do. There is no objective rule book of the universe that definitively states “good people eat X amount of calories in a day, weigh X amount and eat X type of foods.” It is actually totally and completely fine to not give a rat’s arse about your health. Eating more than your body “needs” in order to function optimally does not in any way make you a bad or less valuable person. In fact, caring about health just in order to look good or prove that we’re good enough is, to me, entirely uninspiring and egotistical. A commitment to our health should not come from the need to prove anything to anyone, but rather, from an inspiring reason why. Just like it doesn’t matter if there’s gas in a car that isn’t going anywhere, health is only valuable when it is going to help us fulfill on our greater commitments. Even greater We often get into a mindset of believing that we need to reach a certain health-destination before we are allowed to focus on our bigger commitments. Like making a difference in the world. But really, the inspiration to be authentically committed to our health comes from our greater commitments. We need to remind ourselves that there is a world of a difference between “there is something wrong with me that I have to fix” and “there is nothing wrong with me, and I’m inspired by the possibility of committing myself to my health.” Repeat after me: it is never necessary for me to be upset with myself or where I’m at in order for me to be inspired to create what I want. Completely give up the idea that the harder you are on yourself, the better results you will produce. Find a vision for the world that inspires you—and then, live in alignment with that. No negative self-talk necessary or shame. No self judgements. And o self-inflicted punishments. Just a loving vision for the world. Nonviolent communication teaches that when we get past moralistic judgements of rightness and wrongness, we can step into a radically different way of judging. We can begin asking “is this behavior serving life?” rather than, “do I deserve to be rewarded or punished?” Binge Eating is Not the enemy We need to altogether get past the kind of thinking that leads us to see enemies. And begin to understand that punishment is a losing game and reinforces the notion that violence is a way of getting what we want. Remember that food is not an enemy. Binge eating is not the enemy. Our bodies (no matter what they look like) are not enemies. Emotions (no matter what they feel like) are not enemies. Then, we can set boundaries around food as an act of service and self compassion rather than punishment.
Why Can’t I Stop Binge Eating?
You try SO hard to stop. You hate binge eating and the terrible physical and emotional feelings that go along with it. But maybe you deserve feeling terrible? Maybe you deserve to be punished. But you really, really just want to find a way to stop… Before you can stop binge eating, you need to know the mindset that’s leading you to binge. What is that mindset? It’s the belief that it’s effective to punish and deprive yourself. Before you can break the binge eating cycle this myth must be fully understood and finally debunked. Punishment Punishment is a big part of the binge eating cycle. Studies have shown that if a rat is shocked after pressing a lever that it had been conditioned to press (through intermittent reinforcement), that it will proceed with caution the next time it presses the lever. But will still go on to press the lever the exact number of times that a non-shocked rat would. Punishment doesn’t lead to behavior change, but the desire to avoid the punisher. And in the case of binge eating, the source of the punishment is you. So in this case, punishment only results in increased self-evasion. Punishing ourselves for eating “too much” or eating “unhealthy” foods does not actually change our tendency to do so. It only makes us want to avoid ourselves. And avoiding ourselves is the reason that we binge eat in the first place! It is a positive feedback loop that continually reinforces itself. Therefore, punishment is entirely counterproductive. But we continue punishing ourselves for “bad” eating behavior (even though there is no such thing), because we have internalized diet culture values that profit off shame and dissatisfaction. The “there’s always something terribly wrong with me that I need to fix” mentality of diet culture has taught us divide ourselves into two parts: the authority figure and the punishable offender. When our inner punishable offender has “acted out of line” by over-eating, we think it’s time for our inner authority figure to crack down and control the situation. But in this case, control is the problem – not the solution. Believing that we have to control a part of ourselves only creates a sense of inner division. We start to believe that there’s a “bad” part of ourselves that needs to be fixed. Rebelling against authority So we create an inner dictator in order to control the perceived “bad” part of ourselves. However, we tend to resent authority figures. And try to hide from them. And disobey them. Really, we do whatever the heck we can to prove to them that they can’t and don’t control us. Hence our “acting out.” We are trying to heal our inner division and prove to our inner dictator that it doesn’t have power over us. But instead we just end up pendulum swinging back and forth between, assuming the role of the inner dictator and the punishable offender who rebel against the dictator’s rule. This dichotomy leaves no room for healing this division. Neither the rebellious offender nor the authority figure is concerned with a true, authentic, and well-rounded commitment to health (which includes adopting a compassionate attitude towards ourselves). The offender and the authority figure are concerned only with the world of right and wrong and good and bad, not that which is objectively life-giving. We need to stop cycling between these two separate parts of ourselves and begin coming from a place of whole-hearted commitment to loving ourselves. So if punishment doesn’t work, what does the solution look like? Find out in my next article…
You Are Not A Dirty Girl
Image: @vinganapathy hen I was a little girl, I was excited by everything and totally unafraid of making a fool of myself or failing. Because I never felt the need to prove myself, I only did things that really inspired me. I certainly wasn’t a dirty girl. I wrote poems and dramatically read them to my class. Calling myself an undercover mermaid, I even wore an Ariel costume under all of my clothes. I created mudslides in the pouring rain; started a “restaurant” in our garage and sold saltine crackers for $1 a piece. Starring in dance performances at family gatherings with zero concerns about what other people thought of me was the norm. I thought I could do no wrong. But then, one day when I was 7, my world came crashing down on me when I was sexually assaulted by an older boy. I thought that I would never feel clean or good again. There must have been a part of me that wanted it to happen. Some sick, gross, dirty, bad, wrong part of me. I felt like the dirty girl. The Early Years The next 13 years of my life were consumed with trying to compensate for feeling dirty and not good enough. I didn’t want anyone to know that I was secretly a bad girl, so I did everything in my power to be good. In middle school, sometimes I slept only a few hours a night to make sure that I got perfect scores on my exams. But I still didn’t feel clean; didn’t feel good enough. There was a deep-rooted fear that others would find out my secret. That I was bad. In high school, I was in all honors classes and still got straight A’s. I held leadership positions in four different clubs and was captain on the debate team. My time was spent volunteering, teaching classes, starting my own tutoring business, and writing for the school paper. On top of all that, I went vegan and became an animal activist. I was stuck in The Achievement Trap. Still not good enough, still not clean. I must be a dirty girl. The Modeling Years Towards the end of high school, I started modeling. The industry promised me that I could be world renowned for my beauty. I thought that this, if true, would finally make me feel good enough. Modeling would finally make me feel clean. Soon, my need to prove my worth extended beyond just grades, extracurricular activities and accomplishments. I looked at my body and thought that any fat that I had might reveal to others that I actually wasn’t good enough. I thought it might betray to the outside world that I was actually bad and gross. So, I started dieting. To feel clean again, prove my worth, hide the bad part of me. One day, after leaving a casting where the models were rail-thin, I went to the bathroom and saw how my thighs spread out over the toilet seat. “Still not thin enough,” I thought. I pulled up my shirt and saw how my stomach rolled when I bent over. “Not good enough,” I thought. The refrains from my childhood echoed hauntingly again: I need to be good. I need to be clean. I was already restricting. The thought that I would have to restrict even more to feel good enough was sickening. I felt desperate as I cried and hyperventilated in the bathroom stall. From then on, I ate less and less. I’d frequently check the back of my thighs in the mirror. If I saw dimples, I’d eat even less. I’d bend over to check if my skin rolled. If it did, I took it as a signal to eat even less. My constant mental analyzation of how many calories I took in and burned completely prevented me from connecting with others and enjoying life experiences. The Diagnosis Then, I was diagnosed with anorexia. Although the modeling industry told me I looked great, my doctor told me that my body had begun to eat away at my liver. I dieted in order to numb myself from the feeling of being bad that crept in whenever I wasn’t achieving. The emotional hunger I suppressed was so much greater than my hunger for food. I also suppressed my cravings for nurturing, self-acceptance, pleasure, vulnerability, connection, and relaxation. It seemed wrong to want these things. I associated these desires with the same part of me that I thought must have wanted to be assaulted. The bad part of me that must have deserved it. The part of me that I was afraid would take over if I stopped achieving for a second. I only allowed myself to want what I thought I should want: to be productive, high-achieving, and disciplined. The restrictive eating, straight A’s, and over-involvement persisted in college. On top of modeling and working two part time jobs, I founded and ran a farm animal activism club that won “Organization of the Year.” I got a leadership service award. I held weekly community dinners and activist conferences. In efforts to be good I didn’t drink or party, I went to the gym nearly every day. I was so good. I felt that if I slowed down, let up, or released some control, that the floodgates would open. The shameful parts of myself that I had worked so hard to hide for so long would be revealed. I feared that others would finally figure out that I was actually a bad, wrong, gross little girl. I feared that if I let down my defenses, that no one would love me anymore. Truly unleashed the real me meant that others might discover the ‘bad me’. The Breaking Point One day, I was feeling disgusting because I had eaten a big muffin for breakfast and I thought I could feel the calories turning into fat on my body. My way of fixing this feeling was to run so hard that my body had to consume
The Beauty Battle: A Poem About the Culture of Competition
They came ready to battle, And said “it’s what we’re supposed to do!” Prepared to fight till death, Because their town had told them to. They faced against their sisters, In each hand there was a sword. Their minds were set on winning, The badge of beauty, their reward. They barely knew each other, For their town had done away, With the place they used to gather, To talk and laugh and play. And so the sisters fought each other, Unsure what they were fighting for. And the judges sat and watched them, Ready to silently keep score. But just before they raised their swords, And began this brutal game, One girl threw her sword aside, Said “this is crazy, we’re all the same!“ We do not have to fight for beauty, In order to survive. From beating one another down, True beauty does not derive. Why would we compete for beauty? It’s not a scarce resource! It’s uniquely there in all of us, It is not won through force. The town likes us to go to battle, Because they think it’s fun, To watch us cut each other down, But I, for one, am done! These judges have no authority, Unless we say they do, And I say they haven’t got the right, To say whose beauty’s true! If we put down our shields and swords And come together we’ll realize, Far greater than any badge of beauty, Is friendship as our prize. Image Source
Why I Encourage You to Ditch Your Weight Loss Goals
’m going to say something radical. Weight loss battles (sometimes) allow us to indefinitely postpone taking responsibility for having to pursue our dreams. We pretend like we need to lose weight in order to have what we really want, when in fact sometimes it’s just easier to believe that than to go after what we truly desire. We claim that we need to lose weight before we can have the partner, job or lifestyle that we want. Then we go through never-ending cycles of deprivation and allowance, chasing the elusive loss of that five, 10, 50, 100 pounds. We’re trapped in the illusion that we’ll be better equipped to be who we want to be when we weigh less. This extra weight serves as our excuse for why we don’t/can’t have what we want. Our (real or imagined) extra weight is our alibi. It gets us off the hook for having to go out and get it. But when we’re honest with ourselves, we discover that we wouldn’t even know what to do if we didn’t have that excuse. Many of us put all our eggs in the weight loss basket. We avoid going after the lives we crave full-throttle. We tell ourselves we’ll start on our dreams once we’ve hit our “target weight.” But when it comes down to it, it’s entirely possible to feel sexy, proud, confident, happy, healthy, connected, powerful, fulfilled and accomplished at any weight. We can start a business, find a loving partner, have fun, be adventurous, get rich, feel healthy and vibrant, regardless of that “extra” weight. Telling ourselves that the extra weight is preventing us from being and acting the ways we would like to is a cop out. It’s like saying “I’d love to go skydiving, but I have brown hair.” What’s brown hair got to do with sky diving? Nothing. What do our stomach rolls have to do with our ability to start our own successful business? Nothing. There’s nothing wrong with losing weight if that would be healthy for us. But we have to be clear with ourselves about why we really want to lose weight and make sure our weight loss goal isn’t letting us avoid responsibility for actually going after what we want. Sometimes focusing on a weight loss goal is easier than focusing on our dreams. Some of us really don’t know what we want anymore. We’ve numbed our true calling with weight loss battles for so long that we can’t even feel what really inspires us. So here’s an exercise to help you get back in touch with what you really want, and see what might be underneath your weight loss goal: If you had your perfect body, how would you live differently? What way would you be? How would you feel? Now, visualize yourself being and acting that way in the body you’re in now. It’s not our weight that’s stopping us — it’s our belief that we have to lose weight before we’re ready to be who we want to be. If we could have what we wanted to have now, rather than when we lose 10 or 100 pounds, wouldn’t we? It’s like what Glinda told Dorothy, at the end of her journey trying to get home along the Yellow Brick Road: she realized she had the power to get home all along. She only believed that she had to face those challenges first. We too can come home to our truth, right now. We don’t need to wait to achieve a goal that may or may not ever happen. Whoever we want to be, whatever we want to accomplish — who we are right now is enough for that. If we try to prove our worth by losing weight, we will waste the precious time we could be using in service of what really matters. So let’s cut to the chase, and get to the root of what we really want. When we’re working whole-heatedly towards our dreams, our weight becomes irrelevant. We know that we can live the life we’ve imagined regardless of the number on the scale.
Prison of Mind: A Poem on Treating Yourself With Compassion
You have done it again You’ve committed a crime You must sentence yourself To a prison of mind. Your crime was a muffin: not one worth forgiving A body with fat Is not fit for free living Dark cell, you’re alone As you wallow in shame But you know you deserve it No one else is to blame So you work on repenting, Your sins through depriving, But you’re starving already, You’re barely surviving, You truly believe That the way to get free, Is by treating yourself like your own enemy, But, my love, You are wrong It just isn’t true The key to your freedom Is in there with you The jury is back Your sentence was wrong You are guilty of nothing Innocent all along You must trust this consensus Do not have a doubt There is no warden present You may let yourself out Artwork by ©2016 defectivebarbie
How to Honor Your Body
You cannot just honor your body, On those rare “I am feeling good” days, Your love for her cannot depend on, How you think you look or what you weigh, Like a child, she needs your attention, Needs you to sit with however she feels, Show her of life’s true abundance; When born into her, that was the deal. Listen to her soft-spoken language, Even when hearing her is tough, Even when her voice is a whisper, While the mind loudly yells: “you’re not enough.” Listen when her tiredness begs you, To retreat into comfort and calm, Even when the ego compels you, To silence her words and drag on. Listen to what she needs more of, Whether nourishment for body or soul, Do not ever fear her desires, For a trustful surrender’s the goal. If you punish her, hurt her or numb her, Or you mistrust her whispered requests, It is not self-control that she’s lacking, But compassion of which you’re bereft, Know that she’s never demanding, She won’t force you to give her the time, But tuning her out will divide you, Into two parts: a body and mind, And wherever you find there’s division, Almost always there’ll ensue a war, So rather than fighting against her, Know it’s her that you’re here fighting for. Artwork by ©2016 defectivebarbie
How to Stop Using Hunger to Numb Your Emotions
I used to need to feel hungry in order to feel safe. I believed that any “unnecessary” fat on my body (read: fat that could, through whatever means, be starved off or turned to muscle) signified weakness. If I had fat, I thought it meant that I was out of control. That I had allowed myself more than I needed, more than I deserved. I only felt safe from the threat of loss of control when I was hungry. The sharp sensation of hunger was my evidence that I would not be ruled by my desires. The emptiness in my stomach temporarily silenced my worries of eating too much. Hunger was my repentance. My assurance that I was strong, that I was in control. My nutritionist told me that if I listened to my body and ate when I was hungry until I was full, that my body would reach its optimal weight naturally. She said that everyone’s body is different and that I shouldn’t impose my mind’s idea of how my body should be upon my actual body. She said that my mind has no idea how to guide my body to its optimal health. I believed her, but I didn’t trust myself. If I ate until I was full, then I would have no evidence of my strength or worth. My hunger pains and emaciated body—my security blanket—would be gone. I would have no way of verifying whether or not I could control myself. I believed that I needed to beat back the pains of my hunger, or else it would rule me. I believed that if I gave the desiring part of myself an inch, it would take a mile. First, I thought, I would be allowing myself to eat until I was full, then I would be eating half a pan of brownies as a snack, then I would be getting black-out drunk every night, sleeping around and living recklessly and harmfully. I felt that if I released some control, the floodgates would open, and an insatiable, slovenly beast would emerge from within me. I would go on an unchecked rampage of consumption. I truly feared my unleashed self. It took years of compulsive control for me to realize why I was so scared of my desires. I fundamentally believed that I was not allowed to have what I really wanted until I proved that I was “worthy” enough. So I would rather numb my desires than feel them because not feeling anything was easier than wanting the fulfillment that I couldn’t have. I thought it was better to numb feeling totally than to take the risk of allowing feelings to be there that I might not know how to deal with. I realized that the hunger I suppressed was so much greater than my hunger for food. I dieted in order to suppress my cravings for nurturing, the allowance of emotion, sacredness, pleasure, intimacy, connection, vulnerability, and self-expression. I felt that I was wrong to want these things. I only allowed myself to want what I thought I should want: to be productive, high-achieving, disciplined and well-known. So I broke myself up into two parts: that which achieves and that which desires. The desiring part of myself was the part that had been hurt in the past–when I felt rejected, when I wanted love and couldn’t get it, when I felt ashamed or betrayed. So I thought it was better to numb this part of myself than allowing myself to get hurt again. I was battling against myself: the achieving part trying to conquer the desiring part. The desirer threatened my ability to achieve and thereby prove my worth, so I rejected this part of myself. We all have a rejected self: a part of us that we do not permit to be allowed and expressed. My eating disorder was really just me trying my best to hide the parts of me that I had rejected. I feared that my feelings might expose my rejected self, so I went to great lengths to repress and numb them. In her book Eastern Body, Western Mind, Anodea Judith explains that when we reject a part of ourselves, we “deny an essential part of our wholeness”. Since a part of ourselves is not actually divisible from the whole, we are forced to numb our whole selves. Judith explains that when our true cravings are numbed, “secondary pleasures take over, such as the pleasure of drinking, drugs, avoiding responsibility, sexually acting out, or over/[under]eating.” Numbing behavior can even take the form of perfectionism or workaholism. But these numbing tactics can never truly satisfy our longing for wholeness, and always leave us craving more. It’s like drinking salt water to quench our thirst. It only leaves us thirstier. We can never be thin enough, perfect enough, rich enough, accomplished enough, drunk enough, high enough, full enough. The only true antidote to numbing behavior is to embrace the rejected parts of ourselves. Indeed, this is the intention of many contemplative practices. Yoga means to yoke or to unite, religion (re-ligion like ligament) means to bring back together. We meditate in order to bear witness to the whole experience of ourselves without resistance or judgment. Each of these paths are meant to lead us back to our whole selves. As Psychiatrist and author, Theodore Isaac Rubin stated, “I must learn to love the fool in me–the one who feels too much, talks too much, takes too many chances, wins sometimes and loses often, lacks self-control, loves and hates, hurts and gets hurt, promises and breaks promises, laughs, and cries. It alone protects me against that utterly self-controlled, masterful tyrant whom I also harbor and who would rob me of my human aliveness, humility, and dignity but for my Fool.” I realized that the answer is never to numb, by whatever means, the part of ourselves that we keep in shadow. Indeed, as Judith stated, “keeping the shadow in chains requires a great
